• Home
  • About Me
  • Blog
  • Books
    • The Power of Visual Storytelling
    • The Laws of Brand Storytelling
  • Speaking
  • Contact

The Marketer’s Storybook: Authenticity, Algorithms & the Fight for Signal

Blog
Posted by jessicagioglio - 0 comments

This week’s stories feel like a referendum on what marketing is becoming in an AI-mediated, attention-starved world. Some brands are chasing the next hot narrative at almost any cost. Others are doubling down on clarity, craft, and credibility. The common thread is not technology itself. It is the growing battle over who gets seen, who gets trusted, and who gets remembered.

You can see it in Allbirds’ dramatic pivot from sustainable footwear to AI infrastructure, in brands using “no AI” disclaimers as an authenticity signal, and in Walmart building a creator-commerce machine designed for a world where search starts on social. Even the more playful stories, from e.l.f.’s true-crime mockumentary to NASA-grade iPhone imagery, point to a deeper shift: marketing now has to work for people and for the systems increasingly shaping what people see.

That makes this week’s mix especially instructive. The brands winning attention are not just making more content. They are sharpening their signal, tightening their story, and giving both humans and algorithms clearer reasons to care.

Let’s dive in.

This Week’s Marketing Stories

A curated mix of breaking news, insights, and trends, each with actionable takeaways to inspire your brand storytelling.

1. Allbirds Loses Its Wings, Then Tries on an AI Narrative

Allbirds has gone from poster child of sustainable, Silicon Valley-friendly footwear to one of the more surreal pivots of the year. After agreeing to sell its intellectual property and other assets for $39 million, the company announced a shift into AI compute infrastructure under the name NewBird AI, a move that sent its market value surging from roughly $21 million to about $148 million in a day.

The contrast is striking because Allbirds once stood for something genuinely differentiated. It built early momentum through material innovation, direct-to-consumer simplicity, and a sustainability story that resonated with both tech culture and consumers looking for a cleaner alternative to traditional sneakers. That clarity frayed over time as growth slowed, customer acquisition got harder, the sneaker market cooled, and the brand drifted away from its core.

What makes the AI pivot so revealing is not whether it will work operationally. It is what it says about the market’s incentive structure. Wall Street is still willing to reward a company for attaching itself to the hottest category of the moment, even when the strategic connection feels tenuous. That can create a short-term valuation pop, but it also raises bigger questions about what remains of a brand once its founding story is severed from its business model.

Key Takeaway:
A strong brand can buy you time, but it cannot save you from strategic drift. Allbirds is a reminder that when a company loses sight of its core customer and foundational story, the temptation to chase the next market narrative gets much stronger. Brands should treat clarity as an asset worth protecting, especially when external pressure makes reinvention look more exciting than focus. Read more here and here.

2. Artemis II Turns the iPhone Into a Deep-Space Storytelling Device

The Artemis II mission delivered a remarkable marketing-adjacent moment without behaving like marketing at all: astronauts used an iPhone 17 Pro Max to capture images and video of Earth from deep space, including a widely shared “Earthset” shot from behind the Moon. The footage and images felt immediate, personal, and culturally legible in a way traditional mission photography often does not.

That matters because the images collapse a familiar consumer object and an extraordinary human achievement into the same frame. A smartphone is not replacing NASA’s professional equipment, but it is changing the texture of the story. The visuals feel closer to lived experience, more like something a person witnessed than something an institution documented for the record.

It also shows how modern storytelling increasingly depends on recognizability. The iPhone detail is sticky because it gives audiences a way into the story. It makes space exploration feel both more awe-inspiring and oddly more relatable. That is a useful lesson for brands trying to translate complex, distant, or technical achievements into something people can emotionally process.

Key Takeaway:
Sometimes the most powerful story bridge is a familiar object. The Artemis imagery works because it humanizes a highly technical mission through a device people use every day. The virality of these images also raises a bigger question. In a time where brands are well-oiled machines of ceding established influencers when new devices come out, this moment is proof that less conventional voices can carry a similar weight. If I were advising the influencer marketing team at Apple (or their competitors wink wink), I would be thinking about who else I can gift my latest tech to in order to drive more moments like this that feel accidental – but aren’t. Read more

3. ‘No AI’ Is Becoming a Marketing Signal in Its Own Right

As AI-generated imagery and video flood feeds, brands are beginning to market the absence of AI as a form of differentiation. Aerie has sharpened its existing authenticity platform by pledging not to use AI-generated bodies or people, while brands like Le Creuset and Coterie are explicitly telling audiences when content was made without AI assistance.

The shift is rooted in genuine consumer skepticism. According to surveys cited by The Wall Street Journal, many consumers now question whether the content they see online is real, and a meaningful portion prefer brands that either disclose AI usage or avoid it in customer-facing marketing. In other words, authenticity is no longer just a philosophical stance. It is becoming a practical trust signal.

What is especially interesting is that these brands are not anti-AI absolutists. They are drawing a more nuanced line, using AI where it improves operations or minor post-production tasks while refusing to let it substitute for the human moments that define the brand. That distinction is likely to matter more as disclosure expectations rise and regulators begin to step in.

Key Takeaway:
In an AI-saturated media environment, transparency can become part of the brand experience. “No AI” is emerging as a shorthand for craft, care, and credibility, especially in categories where trust is fragile. Brands should be clear not just about whether they use AI, but where they refuse to let it replace human meaning. Read more

4. Beloved by Humans, Invisible to AI

One of the more important ideas this week came from Adweek: brands can be culturally loved by people and still be practically invisible to AI systems. Craig Elimeliah argues that the same kind of clarity now helping brands like Nike, Starbucks, and Burberry reconnect with consumers also helps them become more legible to the algorithms and AI assistants increasingly mediating discovery and purchase.

The argument is not that those brands re-centered themselves for AI. It is that a clear origin story, consistent narrative, and well-documented point of view happen to be exactly what machines can parse. By contrast, fragmented brands leave gaps that models fill with inference or omission. In AI-generated answers, there is often no page two. A brand is surfaced clearly, surfaced inaccurately, or not surfaced at all.

That makes brand clarity newly operational. This is no longer just about emotional resonance or distinctiveness in a campaign sense. It is about machine readability. The next era of brand strategy will belong to companies that can hold enough emotional truth for humans while also being structurally understandable to systems.

Key Takeaway:
A brand story now needs to travel across two audiences: people and machines. The same clarity that drives human recall increasingly drives AI visibility too. If your brand cannot clearly document what it is, who it is for, and why it matters, you risk disappearing from the conversations that shape tomorrow’s discovery. Read more

5. e.l.f. Turns Bathroom Clutter Into Entertainment Infrastructure

e.l.f.’s new mockumentary “Vanity Vandals” reframes messy bathroom counters as a kind of beauty-related true crime, complete with a 10-minute film, a live Twitch watch party, Roblox activation, contest, and limited-time bundles. The premise is playful, but the strategy is grounded in real consumer behavior and category dynamics, including the sheer volume of affordable beauty products people now buy and accumulate.

The execution is classic e.l.f.: culturally fluent, entertainment-first, and platform-native. The brand is not just running a campaign. It is building a mini media universe around a consumer truth, then extending that world across digital, gaming, commerce, and community touchpoints. That is what makes the work feel bigger than a one-off film.

There is also a commercial logic underneath the comedy. e.l.f.’s affordability is not treated as a discount message. It is reframed as the very reason vanities are overflowing in the first place. That is a smart inversion, turning abundance into both a joke and a proof point.

Key Takeaway:
The strongest entertainment-led marketing is still anchored in a product truth. e.l.f. shows how brands can turn everyday consumer behavior into a story world that spans culture and commerce at once. When a joke reinforces the brand’s value proposition, it works harder than humor alone. Read more

6. Hershey Learns the Hard Way That Some Recipes Are Memory Structures

Hershey says it will restore classic recipes across all Reese’s products after backlash over certain seasonal and specialty items that used compound coatings instead of the traditional chocolate consumers expected. Core Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups were not changed, but the company is now standardizing the classic formula across formats starting in 2027.

This is a useful reminder that product changes are not merely operational decisions when the product carries deep emotional familiarity. Consumers often experience iconic formats not as interchangeable variants but as memory structures. Once taste or texture shifts, even slightly, the change can feel like a brand-level betrayal rather than a formulation tweak.

In a high-cost environment, it is understandable why companies look for margin relief. The problem is that cost-conscious substitutions can collide with decades of sensory brand equity. Brands can stretch many things. Ritual is not usually one of them.

Key Takeaway:
Consumers do not just remember iconic products intellectually. They remember them physically. Hershey’s reversal shows how product consistency is often part of brand storytelling, especially when taste and texture are central to memory. In categories built on ritual and nostalgia, reformulation risk is brand risk. Read more

7. InStyle Is Building Shows, Not Just Social Posts

InStyle’s social-first mockumentary series “The Intern” has generated more than 36 million views across eight seasons and 40-plus episodes, while its newer companion series “The Boss” has already reached 2.3 million views. What began as a creative experiment has turned into a genuine audience engine and a monetizable editorial format.

What stands out here is the strategic ambition. InStyle is not treating social as a distribution channel for magazine content. It is treating social as a programming environment. The series are designed to entertain first, stand alone episode by episode, and introduce new audiences to the brand through recurring characters, creator guests, and office-sitcom dynamics.

That is especially notable in a media landscape still trying to figure out how editorial brands stay culturally relevant with younger audiences. InStyle seems to understand that consistency of format can matter as much as consistency of voice. The audience does not need another post. It needs something to come back for.

Key Takeaway:
Recurring formats can be stronger than one-off content bursts because they train audience behavior over time. InStyle’s model suggests that brands and publishers alike should think less like campaign planners and more like showrunners. If people anticipate the next drop, you are no longer just reaching them. You are building habit. Read more

8. IAMS Turns Baggage Claim Into a Joke About Digestion

IAMS took over baggage claim at Orlando Sanford International Airport with an outdoor installation called “Smooth Deliveries,” using oversized pet rear imagery and humor to spotlight digestive health benefits tied to its PROACTIVE 5 nutrition system. The activation also extended into social through a partnership with pet influencer @brodiethatdood.

It is a hilarious, eye-catching visual, but a strategically smart one. The airport setting makes the “smooth deliveries” line instantly legible, while the brand message about gut health lands without becoming too clinical or overly worthy. That balance is hard to get right in pet nutrition, where health benefits can easily become dry.

The campaign also shows how brands can use place creatively without overcomplicating the idea. This is not a tech-heavy activation. It is a contextual one. The media placement is doing part of the storytelling work, which makes the whole thing feel cleaner and more memorable.

Key Takeaway:
Context can do a lot of creative heavy lifting when the brand idea is simple enough to travel. IAMS turns an awkward product benefit into a laugh-out-loud, highly shareable public moment by matching the message to the medium. Sometimes smart media placement is what unlocks the joke and the brand truth at the same time. Read more

9. Walmart Keeps Building the Creator-Commerce Operating System

Walmart’s creator strategy continues to look more like infrastructure than experimentation. At ANA’s Media Conference, the retailer outlined how it is using creators not just for reach but for search relevance, product discovery, and conversion, all through a growing Walmart Creator program that lets creators monetize shoppable content and connect directly with marketplace sellers.

What is especially telling is Walmart’s emphasis on intentional keyword strategy and creator flexibility. The company understands that social discovery increasingly begins with search-like behavior inside platforms, and that the best creator content is not what a brand scripts most tightly but what a creator can make feel native to audience behavior.

The broader implication is that social commerce is becoming an operating model, not a channel add-on. Walmart is building tools, incentives, and measurement systems that make creator participation more scalable across its ecosystem. That is a very different ambition from simply sponsoring influencer posts.

Key Takeaway:
The next phase of creator marketing is less about campaigns and more about systems. Walmart is building a structure where creators, sellers, search behavior, and commerce all work together. Brands that still treat creator activity as a side tactic risk missing the bigger organizational shift underway. Read more

10. Consumers Want AI Search Utility Without AI Search Ads

A new eMarketer item citing Ipsos data found that 63% of U.S. adults say ads in AI search results would make them trust those results less. That skepticism matters because AI-powered search is already influencing purchase decisions, even as users remain wary of commercialization inside those environments.

The tension here is familiar but newly important. Consumers are showing they will use AI-assisted discovery when it feels useful, but that trust is fragile. The more obviously monetized the environment becomes, the more the perception of neutrality can erode. In AI search, credibility may be the product before any ad inventory becomes the business model.

That suggests a sequencing issue for marketers. Many teams are eager to figure out how to buy their way into AI-mediated experiences. The smarter question may be how to earn presence in ways that do not undermine the trust that makes those experiences valuable in the first place.

Key Takeaway:
Just because a new surface can take ads does not mean it should, at least not immediately. In AI search environments, trust is the scarce asset. Brands should focus first on being accurately represented, genuinely useful, and algorithmically legible before assuming paid placements will strengthen the relationship. Read more

My Stories

Turning Volatility Into Opportunity

I recently joined Caroline Fairchild on her Leadership On New Terms series for a conversation on building a career that compounds beyond any single role. We covered everything from my early days at TripAdvisor and Dunkin’ to why I stepped off the traditional CMO track to build a fractional model before it was even a recognized category, and how that decision has created more flexibility and resilience in today’s volatile market.

A few themes stood out: why scope creep is the biggest risk in fractional work, how the CMO role is fragmenting (and why fractional leadership is absorbing that shift), and why the real demand for “storytellers” is actually a coherence problem, not a content one. If you’re navigating change, rethinking your role, or building something more independent, this conversation offers a clear lens on where marketing leadership is heading and how to design your career on your own terms. Read the interview here or watch it below.

Boston, Burnout & Behind-the-Scenes Reality

This week, I’m sharing a more behind-the-scenes look at my YouTube journey with a vlog that starts with a 5 a.m. apartment leak and ends with me landing in Boston, slightly sleep-deprived but very grateful for a surprise business class upgrade. It’s a mix of real life and travel, from navigating unexpected chaos at home to squeezing in tennis, packing hand luggage only, and diving straight back into my Boston routines like CVS runs, Sephora stops, and long walks down Newbury Street.

It’s also a reminder that not everything you see in polished travel content reflects what actually happens behind the scenes. Sometimes it’s problem-solving, adapting on the fly, and finding small moments of calm, like a morning skincare ritual or a walk in the snow, that make the experience what it is. If you’re curious about the reality behind the travel, the routines, and the reset moments in between, this one’s for you.

Unlock More of My Stories

Website: JessicaGioglio.com Your one-stop shop for all my books, speaking engagements, and blog posts on marketing and storytelling.

Books:

  • The Power of Visual Storytelling: Learn how to shape a visual story around your brand using images, videos, GIFs, infographics, and more. Get your copy here.
  • The Laws of Brand Storytelling: The definitive guide to using storytelling to win over customers’ hearts, minds, and loyalty. Grab it here.

Social Media:

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter/X
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Let’s connect and keep the conversation going!

Until Next Time

Thank you for being part of this journey. Whether you’re here for marketing trends, storytelling inspiration, or both, I’m so grateful to have you along for the ride.

If you found this newsletter helpful and want to buy me a coffee to say thanks, visit: buymeacoffee.com/jessicagioglio

Jessica Gioglio is the co-author of The Laws of Brand Storytelling and The Power of Visual Storytelling. Professionally, Jessica has led innovative marketing and public relations programs for Dunkin’, TripAdvisor, Sprinklr, Nokia, and more. Today, Jessica is a keynote speaker (book her here) and founder of With Savvy Media & Marketing, a strategic branding, storytelling, and growth marketing consultancy.

Related

Tags: AI, brand storytelling, crisis communications, GEO, Influencer, out of home, SEO, Social Media, storytelling

Share with

The Marketer’s Storybook: Play, Proof & Participation in the Age of Scroll-First Marketing

The Power of Visual Storytelling

Get My Latest Blog Posts!

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

Recent Posts

  • The Marketer’s Storybook: Authenticity, Algorithms & the Fight for Signal
  • The Marketer’s Storybook: Play, Proof & Participation in the Age of Scroll-First Marketing
  • How to Build a Personal Brand That Compounds Over Time
  • The Marketer’s Storybook: Narrative, Commerce & Control in the Age of Engineered Attention
  • The Marketer’s Storybook: Culture, Credibility, and the Architecture of Influence

Categories

  • Blog
  • Speaking Engagements

Tags

Advertising AI April Fools brand journalism brand storytelling cause marketing celebrity Community Management contest crisis communications crisis management customer experience Facebook Fashion Funny Holiday Influencer Instagram I wrote a book! leadership LinkedIn Live Event Luxury marketing out of home Pinterest Real-Time Marketing SEO Snapchat Social Media speaking engagements sports marketing storytelling tech innovation the marketer's storybook This Week In Marketing TikTok Travel Tumblr Twitter UGC video Vine Visual Storytelling YouTube

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Receive my latest blog posts via email. Enter your email address below!

Looking To Get In Touch?

I can be reached at savvybostonian@gmail.com

Search My Blog